State Supreme Court ruling limits local control over tax refund claims
The decision could affect how cities handle disputes over locally imposed taxes
By Ben Triffo, Cal Cities legislative advocate,and Ben Fay, Jarvis Fay partner
A state Supreme Court decision made this summer could have major fiscal and administrative consequences for cities going forward if left unaddressed by lawmakers. The court held that cities can’t require taxpayers to complete local post-payment refund procedures before pursuing litigation.
The case, Tesoro Refining & Marketing Company, LLC v. City of Carson, arose after Carson audited Tesoro, an oil refinery operator. The city determined that the company had underpaid a local tax on refinery and petroleum storage businesses. Tesoro paid the assessment and then filed a refund claim under the Government Claims Act.
Carson denied the claim, and Tesoro sued. The city argued that the lawsuit could not proceed because Tesoro had not completed the city’s administrative refund process, which included submitting a refund claim with the city’s finance director and exhausting an appeal to the city manager.
The lower courts agreed, but the California Supreme Court reversed their decisions. It concluded that the Government Claims Act establishes a statewide process for all refund claims against local governments that preempts all local claim ordinances. Consequently, Carson could not require Tesoro to complete additional administrative steps before pursuing its claim. Instead, once Tesoro paid the tax, it only had to comply with the claim requirements of the Government Claims Act before bringing a lawsuit.
The court’s decision only addressed administrative procedures, not whether the underlying tax assessment was valid or whether a refund was owed. The court explained that its decision does not affect refund procedures provided in state statutes, such as those in the Revenue and Taxation Code. Nor does it impact the general requirement that a party exhaust all non-duplicative administrative remedies for claims, apart from claims for money or damages. The court left open the possibility that a taxpayer could still be required to exhaust prepayment administrative remedies.
What the ruling means for cities
The ruling limits cities’ ability to manage tax disputes through local review and appeal procedures. These processes can help cities correct errors, explain assessments, and resolve disagreements before litigation.
Without the ability to require these steps, cities could face increased litigation costs and uncertainty over disputed tax revenues. For cities with large commercial taxpayers, prolonged disputes could complicate budgeting and long-term financial planning. This, in turn, could limit the resources available for essential public services.
Cities should review their existing refund procedures and consult with their city attorneys to evaluate the impact of this ruling.